Current:Home > MarketsPennsylvania court will decide whether skill game terminals are gambling machines -Wealth Empowerment Academy
Pennsylvania court will decide whether skill game terminals are gambling machines
View
Date:2025-04-18 10:03:45
HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP) — Pennsylvania’s highest court will decide whether the cash-paying electronic game terminals that have become commonplace in convenience stores, bars and elsewhere are unlicensed gambling machines and, as a result, must be shut down.
The state Supreme Court said this week that it will consider an appeal by the attorney general’s office of a lower-court decision that found that what are often called skill games are based on a player’s ability — and not solely on chance, like slot machines and other traditional gambling games.
For years, the state has maintained that the devices are unlicensed gambling machines that are operating illegally and subject to seizure by police. Machine makers, distributors and retailers contend they are legal, if unregulated, games that are not subject to state gambling control laws.
The high court’s decision to take the case is a significant development that could set rules for years to come regarding how the machines are treated under the law, said Jeffrey Rosenthal, a Blank Rome lawyer representing Parx Casino in suburban Philadelphia.
Pennsylvania’s courts and lawmakers have wrestled for years with the legality of the machines. Similar legal fights are playing out in Texas, Virginia and Kentucky.
The court is wading into the legal fight as lawmakers discuss regulating and taxing the devices as part of their closed-door negotiations to finalize an annual budget ahead of the July 1 start of the new fiscal year
The Pennsylvania Lottery and the state’s casino industry oppose skill games and say they are losing revenue to them. Casinos pay a roughly 54% tax on slot machine revenue and say that is an unfair burden when the proliferating skill games pay nothing.
A total number of the skill game terminals remains hard to pin down, although the American Gaming Association estimated there are at least 67,000 in Pennsylvania, more than any other state.
“Thousands of substantially similar devices are cropping up in corner stores and bars throughout the state,” Attorney General Michelle Henry’s office told the court in a brief.
The agency’s lawyers said courts, government and private parties are looking for “clear guidance on the application of the relevant Pennsylvania statutes. Only this court can provide it.”
The court said it will determine whether electronic slot machines are illegal games-of-chance gambling devices if they are manufactured with “a so-called ‘skill’ element that is almost entirely hidden from view and is almost impossible to complete,” and how the term slot machines should be defined.
Commonwealth Court Judge Lori Dumas wrote last year that the first stage in playing the games in question “may be analogous to the experience that a slot machine offers.” But, Dumas wrote, they also include a memory game feature that distinguishes them from the common definition of a slot machine.
The case began in Dauphin County in 2019, when investigators with the state police’s Bureau of Liquor Control Enforcement took the Pennsylvania Skill-branded machines from Champions Sports Bar in Highspire, a few miles south of Harrisburg.
No one was charged with a crime, but Champions was issued an administrative citation. The bar and Capital Vending Company Inc., which owns the machines, sued to get the machines and money back.
A county judge ruled the machines and $525 in cash had to be returned. Commonwealth Court upheld that decision.
Chris Carusone, a lawyer who represents Champions bar, said the machines are integral to the bar and restaurant business sector in Pennsylvania. “They were a lifeline for these businesses coming out of the pandemic,” Carusone said Thursday.
The games allow players to reverse losses by completing memory challenges, which the attorney general’s office has described as involving a minimal element of skill.
The office wrote that the “Follow Me” skill portion “requires quite the eagle eye even to detect this feature, let alone to understand it, let alone to win anything by playing it.”
Bills to ban or regulate skill games are pending in the Legislature, and the skill game industry is urging lawmakers to regulate the machines, at least in part to protect them from seizure.
“These bills show the future of skill games is a public policy debate for the General Assembly, and not for this Court,” the bar and vending company’s lawyers argued in a Supreme Court brief.
veryGood! (5415)
Related
- The FTC says 'gamified' online job scams by WhatsApp and text on the rise. What to know.
- In summer heat, bear spotted in Southern California backyard Jacuzzi
- First August 2023 full moon coming Tuesday — and it's a supermoon. Here's what to know.
- After rebranding, X took @x from its original Twitter owner and offered him merch
- Realtor group picks top 10 housing hot spots for 2025: Did your city make the list?
- JoJo Siwa will 'never' be friends with Candace Cameron Bure after 'traditional marriage' comments
- Rest in Power: Celebrities react to the death of Sinéad O'Connor
- C.J. Gardner-Johnson returns to Detroit Lions practice, not that (he thinks) he ever left
- Jamaica's Kishane Thompson more motivated after thrilling 100m finish against Noah Lyles
- What recession? It's a summer of splurging, profits and girl power
Ranking
- Skins Game to make return to Thanksgiving week with a modern look
- Russia-Africa summit hosted by Putin draws small crowd, reflecting Africa's changing mood on Moscow
- After cop car hit by train with woman inside, judge says officer took 'unjustifiable risk'
- These are the classic video games you can no longer play (Spoiler: It's most of them)
- RFK Jr. grilled again about moving to California while listing New York address on ballot petition
- Dehydration can be exacerbated by heat waves—here's how to stay hydrated
- Dehydration can be exacerbated by heat waves—here's how to stay hydrated
- Tupac Shakur ring sells for record $1 million at New York auction
Recommendation
Man can't find second winning lottery ticket, sues over $394 million jackpot, lawsuit says
Actors take to the internet to show their residual checks, with some in the negative
Man dies after being electrocuted at lake Lanier
The ‘Barbie’ bonanza continues at the box office, ‘Oppenheimer’ holds the No. 2 spot
Intel's stock did something it hasn't done since 2022
Biden administration proposes new fuel economy standards, with higher bar for trucks
The Jackson water crisis through a student journalist's eyes
Is 'Hot Girl Summer' still a thing? Here's where it originated and what it means.